Clicky

Fillfront
← All guides

Fillable PDF vs online form: which should you use?

If you need answers back from other people, use an online form: anyone with a phone can open a link and finish it. A fillable PDF file is the better choice when the person filling it in needs to keep the file, works offline, or has to hand it to someone who only accepts PDFs. Most people who ask us this want the answers and the document, and you can have both.

#How do they compare?

Here is the comparison we'd give a friend, based on the forms we see every day.

Online form Fillable PDF file
Opens on a phone Yes, in the browser that's already there Sometimes. Depends on the app, and on whether the file has real fields
Software needed None A reader that supports form fields. Some official forms need Adobe Acrobat Reader specifically
Missed a required answer Can't send until it's filled Most readers let it go
Closing it halfway Depends on the builder. Ours keeps a draft in that browser for a week Answers are lost unless they saved a copy
How it gets back to you Arrives by itself They save it, find it, attach it, send it
Layout and wording The builder's layout Your page, exactly as designed
Works offline No Yes, once downloaded
Fixing a mistake after sending Edit it, and the next person sees the fix Old copies keep circulating

The rows that decide it are usually the first and the fifth. If your people are on phones, and you need the thing back, the file is working against you.

#When is a fillable PDF file the better choice?

We build an online-form tool, so take this with the appropriate pinch of salt. But there are cases where we'd tell you to send the file.

Pick an online form for nearly everything else: more than a few recipients, anyone likely to open it on a phone, or anything you'll otherwise have to chase.

#What does each journey look like?

The difference is easiest to see when you follow a single form from you to them and back.

Two journeys side by side. Top: a PDF file is emailed, opens in the recipient's reader, may or may not be saved with the answers, then has to be attached to a reply. Bottom: a link opens in the browser, the person presses Send, and a completed PDF arrives. The file route has two steps where the answers can quietly disappear. The link route has none that depend on the recipient's software.

The second amber box is where most fillable PDFs die. A browser's built-in viewer will let you type into a real form field, but the answers only live in that tab until you download or save the file. Close it first and they're gone. Nobody emails to tell you this happened. You just never hear back.

#Is your PDF actually fillable?

Check before you choose, because a lot of documents called "fillable" have no fields in them at all.

The quick test. Open the PDF in Chrome and click on a blank line. If a text cursor appears, it has fields. If nothing happens, the boxes are drawn on and nobody can type into them.

We keep a set of about 80 real forms we use to test our field detection, all uploaded by real people. About a third were made in Canva, and only a couple of those had any usable fields. Over a third of the Canva files had no text layer either, so they behave exactly like scans even though nobody scanned anything. That's usually Canva's "Flatten PDF" box at download time.

Word, Pages, LibreOffice and WPS exports were all flat too. So were files saved through Chrome or Edge's "Save as PDF", which is a common way to flatten a form by accident: the print route draws the fields as pictures of fields.

The free fillable PDF checker's result for a flat PDF: no fillable fields, with 45 likely answer areas spotted. A typical result. The form looks fillable; it isn't. The checker also counts where the answers probably go.

The free fillable PDF checker gives you the same answer without guesswork. If the verdict is flat, you're not choosing between a fillable PDF and an online form any more. Why can't I type in this PDF? covers what to do with each result.

#The fillable PDF that only works in one app

One kind of fillable PDF deserves its own warning, because it causes a lot of "it worked yesterday" confusion.

Many forms made with Adobe LiveCycle Designer use a format called XFA. You'll meet them in government, immigration and tax paperwork. They only work in Adobe Acrobat and Adobe Acrobat Reader.

Left: a browser's PDF viewer showing only a "Please wait..." message instead of the form. Right: the same file in Adobe Acrobat Reader on a computer, showing the form with typeable fields. Same file, two apps. The message on the left is the whole page; the form never appears.

Open one in Chrome, Edge, Firefox, macOS Preview or a phone app and you get a page that says "Please wait... If this message is not eventually replaced by the proper contents of the document, your PDF viewer may not be able to display this type of document." It will not be replaced. Download the file and open it in the free Acrobat Reader on a computer.

If you're the one sending, this is a strong reason not to email an XFA form to people on phones. If a form you used to fill in has stopped cooperating for other reasons, why is my PDF form no longer fillable? walks through the usual causes.

#Can you have both?

Yes, and for most paperwork it's what we'd recommend.

Use the online form to collect: a link, any browser, no app. Keep the PDF as the record: the same page, wording and letterhead you started with, with each person's answers drawn onto it. That matters for anything where the wording is the point, like a lease, a waiver or a statement of work.

This is what Fillfront does. You upload the PDF and it proposes a field at each underscored blank, printed tick box and ruled table cell, labelled from the printed caption beside it. You fix what it missed and share the link. If your recipients like seeing the page, you can let them type straight onto the PDF in their browser instead of a standard form.

Each reply comes back as its own completed PDF, and the answers export as a spreadsheet too. How to collect form responses as completed PDFs shows what that looks like once replies start arriving.

If you'd rather start from a ready-made document, the freelance and client onboarding templates are good examples of paperwork where you want the finished PDF. A statement of work is worth keeping for its scope clause, not for the dates someone typed into it.

Common questions

Which is easier for the person filling it in?

An online form. It opens in the browser already on their phone, needs no app, and tells them about a missed required answer before they send. A fillable PDF only works if their reader supports form fields and they remember to save a copy.

When is a fillable PDF file the better choice?

When the person filling it in needs to keep or pass on the file themselves, when they will fill it in offline, when another organisation insists on a PDF filled in their own software, or when it is an official form you do not control. In those cases send the file.

Can I have both?

Yes. Collect the answers through an online form and have each response drawn back onto your original PDF. You get the reach of a link and the document you need to keep, plus a spreadsheet of the same answers if you want one.

What is the difference between a fillable PDF and a flat PDF?

A fillable PDF contains real form fields that a reader lets you type into. A flat PDF only has the boxes drawn on the page, like a letterhead. They look the same on screen. The free fillable PDF checker tells you which one you have.

Why does a government PDF form say "Please wait" in my browser?

It is probably an XFA form, made with Adobe LiveCycle Designer. Chrome, Edge, macOS Preview and most phone apps cannot display these and show a "Please wait..." page instead. Download the file and open it in the free Adobe Acrobat Reader on a computer.

Which one works better on a phone?

The online form. Some phone apps can type into a real fillable PDF, many cannot, and none can type into a flat one. A link to a web form behaves the same on every phone.

Keep reading

Templates for this

Free tools

Last updated